Which Are You?

Did you know? Want a franchise added? Tell us which one on the contact page. Contact us →

Home › Compare › Sirius Black vs Minerva McGonagall

Sirius Black vs Minerva McGonagall

VS
ESFP

Sirius Black

Harry Potter

ESFP The Performer Enneagram 7

Reckless, charming, and loyal enough to break out of Azkaban for it.

Strengths

  • Unbreakably loyal to his chosen family
  • Fearless in a crisis
  • Warm, funny and easy to love
  • Rejected his family's prejudice as a teenager

Weak spots

  • Acts first and considers consequences later
  • Cruel when he is bored or angry
  • Falls apart when cooped up
  • Sometimes treats Harry like a second James
  • Cannot sit still while others do the planning

Full profile

ISTJ

Minerva McGonagall

Harry Potter

ISTJ The Inspector Enneagram 1

Stern, fair, and secretly the biggest Quidditch fan at Hogwarts.

Strengths

  • Fair even to students from rival houses
  • Calm, decisive leadership in emergencies
  • Stands up to bad authority without flinching
  • High standards that bring out people's best

Weak spots

  • Can seem cold until you know her
  • Dismisses anything vague or unproven
  • Pushes herself well past her limits

Full profile

How they compare

They share 1 of the four letters (Sensing).

Where they split: Extraverted (Sirius Black) vs Introverted (Minerva McGonagall); Feeling (Sirius Black) vs Thinking (Minerva McGonagall); Perceiving (Sirius Black) vs Judging (Minerva McGonagall).

On the Enneagram Sirius Black is a 7 (The Enthusiast) and Minerva McGonagall is a 1 (The Reformer).

On our profiles they are listed as a good match for each other.

Who wins this match-up?

Pick the one you would rather be, or the one you think has the stronger personality.